Indiana’s Best Pizza, Lasagna & Pastas

Papa’s is proud to offer not only Indiana’s Best Pizza, but also homemade Lasagna and many different pasta options. All of our cuisines and sauces are homemade, using only the highest quality ingredients.


Papa’s special

Our signature pizza loaded with toppings

chicken alfredo

Creamy house-made alfredo sauce, chicken and cheese

Pizza Margherita

Garlic-basil infused olive oil with Roma Tomatoes and Basil

Stuffed spinach

Tons of red sauce, cheese and cream spinach with a lid on top


Plus much more!!



Our house made 4-layer family recipe

Chicken parmesan

Hand–breaded chicken with traditional Marinara, served over spaghetti

Marian’s legendary Chicken Tetrazzini

Mama’s legendary recipe is baked to perfection

“build your own” Pasta

Choose from many different pastas, sauces, meats and veggies


Full menu

***Be sure to ask about our Take and Bake Pizzas that you can cook at home!***